First off, just to get this out of the way, yes I’m a Syracuse grad. However, I am also a big fan of the Toledo program and of Tim Beckman as a human being and coach.
I’m looking at this issue as an objective outsider.
Toledo got hosed, but the Syracuse win should NOT be vacated, as Toledo is requesting.
The whole issue obviously stems from an extra point that was ruled good when it was missed. When officials checked the replays, they inexplicably kept the play as is. There’s no disputing how bad the call was. The Big East acknowledged as much afterwards. Of course, by then it was too late. A Ryan Casano field goal in the final seconds of regulation would’ve won it, but instead, it tied the game, sending the game to overtime, where the Rockets lost 33-30.
As bad as the call was, vacating the result might be worse.
Coaches will tell you the game shouldn’t come down to one missed call. There are countless times in the game where mistakes can be corrected. Beckman even said after the game that if his team didn’t give up the touchdown, that whole extra point situation wouldn’t have happened.
And with the game tied in overtime, it’s not like it’s the NFL. Toledo had their chance to score and play defense. The official did not intercept Austin Dantin’s pass in overtime. Syracuse did. That obviously made it easy for the Orange to win it with a field goal that wasn’t close to being disputed.
That said, I understand the outrage. Toledo SHOULD have won the game, but one horribly blown call (at ANY point of ANY game) shouldn’t decide whether the end result should be changed.
THAT would set a horrendous precedent.
I don’t expect the Big East to vacate the win nor do I think they should.
Beckman’s right in calling this whole thing an injustice, but it would be a graver injustice to reverse what Syracuse fairly did to beat Toledo after the erroneous call was made.